Call Us for a Free Consultation 516.569.3030


If the FBI Knocked on My Door and Want to "Just Speak to Me?" Should I Talk to Them Without a Lawyer?

Posted by Mordy Aryeh | Feb 08, 2021 | 0 Comments

The FBI is knocking at your door, and you feel it is better to talk to them and cooperate; after all, you don't have "anything to hide." Even though this might be your first approach, it is best to avoid it and have a wiser strategy.

Although there are many reasons why a federal agent would want to contact you, it is best to never talk to the FBI without a lawyer present.


Because even if you're not guilty or have nothing to hide, it is possible to make mistakes in casual discussions, resulting in severe consequences.

Please avoid thinking that if you refuse to collaborate with the FBI's demands, they will charge you with a crime. You need a criminal defense lawyer by your side to protect you from law enforcement manipulation.

What to Do?

If an FBI agent tries to contact you, it is imperative to remember your rights:

1. The Right to Remain Silent

Everyone has the right to remain silent under the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. You are not forced to respond to any questions.

You only need to answer your name, address, and age. You should need to provide an ID if you're given a citation or if the law enforcement agency requests one.

2. The Right to Receive Proper Legal Advice

It is your privilege to call a lawyer before answering any inquiries. You can request the name, agency, and contact information of the agent who visits or calls you so your lawyer can schedule an interview at any time.

Suppose you agree to talk with the FBI without a lawyer, make sure to never provide false information. Remember, lying to a law enforcement agent can result in severe consequences, including jail time. That's why we strongly suggest calling a lawyer before talking. Keep in mind that law enforcement can use anything you say against you. 

Federal agents are trained to influence and will say and do anything to prove their case. You can admit guiltlessness even if you're trying to protest your innocence. Remain silent.

3. Law Enforcement Agents Can't Enter Your Home Without a Warrant

You have the right to deny access to your home, office, or car without a warrant. If the agent has a warrant, ask to see it. If not, do not let him into your home. If he forces his entry, don't try to stop him. Call your lawyer and declare that the agent entered without your permission.

4. A Warrant for Your Arrest

Suppose the FBI's agent has a warrant for your arrest, request to see it. Even with a warrant, you are under no legal obligation to tell the agent anything other than your name and address. You should go with the agent but remain silent. Request to call a lawyer immediately.

Bottom Line

Federal criminal law is challenging, and you should not attempt to navigate the system alone. You should not talk to a federal agent without a lawyer present under any condition. The only way to protect your rights and avoid FBI manipulation is to remain silent and wait for proper legal advice.

About the Author

Mordy Aryeh

Associate | Mordy primarily works in our civil and commercial litigation department, as well as assisting the firm with corporate and transactional law matters. Mordy is also dedicated to helping...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment


Novak Juhase & Stern is committed to answering your questions about civil litigation, white-collar crime, real estate, Medicaid fraud, corporate law, arbitration, Beth Din, corporate bankruptcy, personal bankruptcy, creditor's rights, foreclosure defense, and business law issues in New York and New Jersey.

We offer a free consultation and we’ll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.